I never thought I wouldnt finish the book, but it was extremely draining.. As author Neil Sheehan described the funeral, it was like an extraordinary class reunion. Confident to the point of arrogance, John Paul Vann had an unbridled sexual appetite that led to the charge of statutory rape that would keep him from attaining the generals status he coveted so dearly, Sheehan writes. Sheehan, who makes his home in Washington now, is 52 and silver-haired. Last edited on 25 February 2023, at 15:43, United States Agency for International Development, Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs, Civil Operations and Rural Development Support, A Bright Shining Lie: John Paul Vann and America in Vietnam, Learn how and when to remove this template message, "Trapped By Vietnam: Before He Could Tell the Tale of a Soldier and a War, Neil Sheehan First Had to Battle His Own Emotions", "Distinguished Service Cross Recipients, Vietnam War, 19561975", "HBO's 'Shining Lie' Draws Early Complaints", Vann's DSC award information at the National Archives, An American Soldier in Vietnam The Rooster and the Tiger, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=John_Paul_Vann&oldid=1141539241, "It was a miserable damn performance." For the baseball player, see. A Bright Shining Lie lives on as a lasting work of scholarship, and a staple of high school and college history and literature course syllabuses. Written by Neil Sheehan, a former Southeast Asian correspondent for United Press International (UPI) and later "The New York Times," this book combines a biography of John Paul Vann, considered by some to be ". Along with almost all Army Air Forces officers of the day, Vann faced a key career decision the following year. He worked for a time in Tokyo, then was sent to Vietnam. Yet the combination of the abuse at home and the absenteeism of a military father caused rifts. Despite the shadow of the charges and the investigation, Vann was promoted to lieutenant colonel in 1961. Vanns first duty was to organize a supply system for the ARVN forces. Back in Washington, Vann prepared a special report on the real situation in Vietnam which so impressed Pentagon staffers that he was . He transformed us into a band of reporters propounding the John Vann view of the war., Which was, as Vann said to an Army historian shortly before he resigned in 1963, the notion that the Americans were helping the South Vietnamese to win the war was one of the bright shining lies., The title of the book was meant to reflect all the ironies and illusions about the war, a conflict Sheehan called layer upon layer of illusion., But the title also reflects the feelings Sheehan came to have for Vann as well. Harkins had finally had enough. The consequences if he was found guilty would be enormous. Among other undertakings, CORDS was responsible for the Phoenix Program, which involved neutralization of the Viet Cong infrastructure. At the time Vietnam was a nation divided. Dzu actually spent more time with Vann than he did with Maj. Gen. Hal McCown, who was Dzus official senior adviser in the IV CTZ. History is who we are and why we are the way we are.. By late 1961 and early 1962, the Kennedy administration started to focus its attention on the conflict in South Vietnam. The Army then assigned him to Korea as a special services officer, coordinating entertainment activities for the soldiers. General Hamlett agreed that the Joint Chiefs of Staff were not getting the full truth about combat in Vietnam. [citation needed], On one of his trips back to the U.S. in December 1967, Vann was asked by Walt Rostow, an advocate of more troops and Johnson administration National Security Advisor, whether the U.S. would be over the worst of the war in six months: "Oh hell no, Mr. Rostow", replied Vann, "I'm a born optimist. Hopkins is the genesis of our familys issues because he was an evil person who molested me and one of my brothers, John Allen says. The girl took a lie detector test and passed. He walks with the aid of a cane, the result of a serious automobile accident in 1974 that badly set back his writing schedule. But they're good people and they can win a war if someone shows them how." A half-century later, the hurt Vann caused the family lingers. Jess Vann talks to everyone now and again, and believes the family isnt close because of lack of proximity and the demands of modern existence, but hes also spent most of his life alone in the mountains, working as an ecologist in Colorado. Three days after the Battle of Kontum, Vann was killed when his helicopter crashed into a grove of trees near a village cemetery. [6], Last edited on 28 September 2022, at 11:11, Robert F. Kennedy Center for Justice and Human Rights, Follow-up call-in interview with Sheehan, December 5, 1988, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=A_Bright_Shining_Lie&oldid=1112841378. At 14, Vann unburdened himself to Hopkins, who persuaded him to join his Boy Scout troop. In the early 1940s he was attending junior college as the United States entered World War II. His climb would therefore have to be a singular one. A Bright Shining Lie: John Paul Vann and America in Vietnam (1988) is a book by Neil Sheehan, a former New York Times reporter, about U.S. Army lieutenant colonel John Paul Vann (killed in action) and the United States' involvement in the Vietnam War. He was this incredibly vigorous guy who would do things nobody else would do. Vann got by on four hours sleep a night and thought nothing of working two eight-hour shifts a day, then using the remaining time for what might politely be termed personal diversion. We all felt a pride in dad for standing up for his beliefs, because he was having a wonderful military career that was cut short, says his eldest son, John Allen Vann, now 69. But Lansdale also tried, without success, to get Vann to brief the JCS. In 1955, with the help of the Americans, South Vietnam had . Vann took the polygraph without incriminating himself, and the Article 32 convening authority subsequently concluded that there was not enough evidence beyond a reasonable doubt to convict him. Westmoreland, however, left the final decision to Lt. Gen. Fred Weyand, the newly appointed commander of U.S. II Field Forces, the senior American commander in the south of the country. While commander of the 25th Infantry Division, Weyand had learned that Vann was right far more often than he was wrong. He was an ardent critic of how the war was fought by the Saigon regime, which he viewed as corrupt and incompetent, and increasingly, on the part of the U.S. military. It was extremely hard on his wife, Susan, and their daughters; the girls were barely in elementary school when he started, and out of the house by the time he finished, with no family vacations to speak of along the way. $24.95 ALL . 5 References. Vanns new assignment in the Pentagon involved managing the financial resources allocated to the Special Forces counterinsurgency program. On June 16, the President met with members of the Vann family at the White House where he awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom posthumously to Mr. Vann. Many of them we can look up; the generals, journalists, public figures, etc have a continued history that we can see elsewhere online, but for others there is nothing. He received the Presidential Medal of Freedom and was the only civilian in Vietnam to receive the Distinguished Service Cross. Mr. Sheehan found himself standing in the back of the chapel. John Paul Vann (July 2, 1924 - June 9, 1972) was a Lieutenant Colonel in the United States Army, later retired, who became well-known for his role in the Vietnam War. Soldiers walking into a Vietnamese town, ca. He died believing he had won his war.. He had two longstanding mistresses in Vietnam; one he forced to get an abortion, the other had a child. Personally involved in targeting during the course of the battle, Vann directed more than 300 B-52 strikes. John Paul Vann (born John Paul Tripp; July 2, 1924 - June 9, 1972) was a lieutenant colonel in the United States Army, later retired, who became well known for his role in the Vietnam War. John Paul Vann's Mysterious Death He said to a Washington Post correspondent at that time, "Any time the wind is blowing from the north, where the B-52 strikes are turning the terrain into a moonscape, you can tell from the battlefield stench that strikes are effective." So he completely reversed his position, his professionalism was gone. Sen. Edward M. Kennedy arrived late, but Joseph Alsop, the columnist who so firmly embodied the voice of Americas blue-blood Establishment, was precisely, politely on time. This two-story farmhouse was once the home of Lieutenant Colonel John Paul Vann, a well-known and vocal Vietnam War hero. He graduated from its high school in 1941, and from its junior college program in 1943. He was an ardent critic of how the war was fought by the Saigon regime, which he viewed as corrupt and incompetent, and increasingly, on the part of the U.S. military. . Book IV details Vann's criticism of the way the war was being fought, his conflict with the U.S. military command and his transfer back to America. It wasnt out of desperation either she was a hard-drinking partyer who kept all her earnings for herself. In April 1963 Vann returned to America. Because of his track record in the field, Vann was the lead candidate to become CORDS deputy for the III Corps Tactical Zone (CTZ). Mr. Sheehan himself makes a smart tactical decision by letting readers get to know Vann as a soldier first. Although they eventually separated, Mary Jane stood by her man for years, even though he didnt care if she suffered. Vanns key military talent was his ability to see the big picture and establish the priorities necessary to accomplish the objective. Four presidential administrations and a societal shift in recognizing Vietnam veterans later, Vann, a former lieutenant. Vann. More than 58,000 United States soldiers died in the Vietnam War, but in the world of letters, the death of a single American civilian came to represent the entire jungle quagmire. Here were all the figures of Vietnam in this chapel. As soon as he left the service in 1962, he went full time with UPI. Book III gives a detailed account of the shambolic. With only a handful of U.S. military advisers and troops on the scene, Americans believed the war seemed easily winnable. ", "This is a political war and it calls for discrimination in killing. Subscribe to receive our weekly newsletter with top stories from master historians. Vanns major test as a field commander came during the Easter Offensive of 1972. Book I tells of Vann's assignment to Vietnam in 1962. John Vann attended public school in Roanoke, Va. [1], Neil Sheehan wrote a Pulitzer Prize-winning Vietnam history and biography of Vann, A Bright Shining Lie: John Paul Vann and America in Vietnam, in which Sheehan also examines two of Vann's alleged career-stunting incidents involving morals charges during his service in West Germany and at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, and how these possibly affected Vann's future actions and resulting career path both in and after Vietnam. SAIGON, South Vietnam, Sat urday, June 10 John Paul Vann, a senior American ad viser and one of the most expe rienced United States officials ever stationed in South Viet mum, was killed in. Other civilians, such as Komer, had held general officer equivalency rank, but Vann was the first to have the authority to direct American troops in battle. In this magisterial book, a monument of history and biography that was awarded the National Book Award and the Pulitzer Prize for Nonfiction, a renowned journalist tells the story of John Vann"the one irreplaceable American in It was an open secret in Saigon and Washington that the Diem government was rife with corruption. In the run-up to the Tet Offensive of 1968, Vann was one of the few Americans besides Weyand who saw and correctly interpreted the intelligence patterns that indicated a massive VC/NVA assault on the SaigonLong BinhBien Hoa area. Vann's wit and iconoclasm did not endear him to many military and civilian careerists but he was a hero to many young civilian and military officers who understood the limits of conventional warfare in the irregular environment of Vietnam. When he first went to Vietnam, he remembered over dinner, my head was filled with the shibboleths of the Cold War. His generation grew up questioning nothing, Sheehan said. While assigned to Rutgers University's ROTC program as an assistant professor of military science and tactics,[5] he received a BS with a concentration in economics and statistics in 1954.[3]. Because a civilian cannot convene courts-martial under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Vann was assigned a military deputy, Brig. [9], "John Vann" redirects here. The disastrous battle at Ap Bac on January 2, 1963, was a turning point for Vann. [3] Vann returned to Vietnam in March 1965 as an official of the Agency for International Development (AID). John Paul Vann went down in a helicopter crash on June 9, 1972. John Paul, his stepbrother and two stepsisters were raised by Frank Vann, a decent, passive man who was intermittently employed and took the brunt of her cruelty. The prologue recounts Vann's funeral on June 16, 1972, after his death in a helicopter crash in Vietnam. John Paul Vann was a charismatic lieutenant colonel in the Army who served as a senior adviser to South Vietnamese troops in the early 1960s, retired from the Army in frustration, then came. In May 1971, Vann moved north to become the senior adviser in II CTZ. It wasnt like that at all, Susan Sheehan said. Despite heroic Americans like Vann, poor American leadership and corrupt South Vietnamese governance ensured American involvement sealed America's fate.5 Neil Sheehan orchestrates a great fugue evoking all the elements of the war". Vann landed under heavy fire at Tan Canh with his helicopter and began evacuating civilians and the wounded. Vann joined his unit, which was placed on the critical Pusan Perimeter until the amphibious Inchon landing relieved the beleaguered forces. But Sheehan, a nocturnal character who writes while most mortals are sleeping, insists it was the vastness of the subjects, Vann and Vietnam, that confounded him. I am particularly interested in what became of his mistresses, Lee and Annie, and his daughter Thuy Vann. The war was accelerating and Vann could not stand to be away from it. Mystery surrounds the infamous burning of the Reichstag in 1933. Weyand presented Vanns case to Abrams in April 1971. [1] The Book-of-the-Month Club grabbed A Bright Shining Lie as a main selection. (Army Chief-of-Staff) William Westmoreland was chief pallbearer. While he was enrolled at Syracuse University in New York in May 1959, Vann was notified by the military police that he was being investigated on charges of statutory rape of a 15-year-old girl while he had been at Fort Leavenworth. He died in a helicopter crash while flying at night in bad weather. When the Korean War began in June 1950, Vann coordinated the transportation of his 25th Infantry Division to Korea. If that was not enough pressure on the family, Vanns youngest son, Peter, was seriously ill and required extensive medical treatment. Tripp married Aaron Frank Vann in 1929, and young John took his new fathers name. When Vann joined the Army in the spring of 1943, a college counselor predicted he would be the kind of soldier who would go beyond the call of duty., But he was also manipulative, a consummate actor. It was before the era of Vietnam protest, before the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. (speaking about the, "I will turn this into a burning Hell" speaking to MACV Team 36 advisor CPT RE McCall in February 1972 regarding the planned NVA offensive in Pleiku Province. In 1942, Aaron Vann officially adopted him. His funeral was attended by such notables as General William Westmoreland, Major General Edward Lansdale, Lieutenant Colonel Lucien Conein, Senator Edward Kennedy, and Daniel Ellsberg. Vann denied the charges. John Paul Vann had secrets, including the reason he left the military. The citation read in part, Soldier of peace and patriot of two nations, the name of John Paul Vann will be honored as long as free men remember the struggle to preserve the independence of South Vietnam., Saigon fell less than three years after Vanns victory at Kontum. After his assignment to IV Corps, Vann was assigned as the senior American advisor in II Corps Military Region in the early 1970s when American involvement in the war was winding down and troops were being withdrawn. You couldnt help feeling you were attending a strange class reunion, Sheehan recalled. of 1 The North Vietnamese, however, had no real experience with pursuit in mobile warfare and failed to follow up aggressively. The 2nd Regional Assistance Command was redesignated the 2nd Regional Assistance Group, and Vanns title was director. Vann completed his Vietnam assignment in March 1963 and left the Army within a few months, having completed 20 years of service. From Tet forward it was an anticlimax, maintained Sheehan, who left Vietnam in 1966. In 1964 an Ohio woman took up the challenge that had led to Amelia Earharts disappearance. Hes a compelling figure: tough, brash, energetic, hardheaded, and with enough charisma for a dozen Audie Murphy movies. Neil Sheehan, A Bright Shining Lie: John Paul Vann and America in Vietnam. As U.S. forces started to draw down in Vietnam, Vann saw an opportunity to redeem his aborted military career through an alternate path, which was to replace McCown as the IV CTZ senior adviser when McCowns tour ended in May 1971. A Bright Shining Lie was published to great acclaim. Yet, Sheehan added, Vann fascinated me because of who he was, but also because it made him an even better metaphor for the war., Sheehans book weighs heavily toward the early years of the war, with only about 50 pages devoted to the period after the Tet offensive in 1968 until 1972, the year Vann was killed. Although he succeeded there for nearly two years, he missed Vietnam and angled to return. November 9, 1988. Vann witnessed firsthand how Diem refused to implement needed political and military reforms and how his corrupt brother, Ngo Dinh Nhu, rewarded friends in the military. Seeing how badly the Diem regime was responding to the ever-growing Communist threat, and the lack of military progress against the VC, Vann decided he had to tell his superior officers, and anyone else who would listen, just how badly things were going in Vietnam. He fought back through the news media, leaking information sometimes through Mr. Sheehan, who eventually was hired by The New York Times, some of which directly contradicted what was coming out Washington. Vann also met with the military staff of Defense Secretary Robert McNamara and with presidential assistant Roswell Gilpatrick, as well as with CIA operative Maj. Gen. Edward Lansdale, who told Vann he should stick to things he knew firsthand and skip the gossip about what was going on in Saigon. These officers knew that such questioning of the way the war was going could lead to the end of their military careers, but decided to pursue the truth regardless. Vann had dodged a huge bullet. These men suffered from disease He was a bitter soldier when he left the Army in 1963. As the senior adviser to a South Vietnamese infantry division in the Mekong Delta in 1962, the first year American correspondents began to descend on Vietnam, Vann was the de facto contact for U.S. journalists who arrived to cover the war. The full truth about combat in Vietnam climb would therefore have to be away it!, 1963, was a hard-drinking partyer who kept all her earnings for herself the era of Vietnam 1966... While commander of the Americans, South Vietnam had 1964 an Ohio took. Tan Canh with his helicopter crashed into a grove of trees near a village.. Have to be away from it things nobody else would do things nobody else would do things else... Vietnam protest, before the era of Vietnam protest, before the era Vietnam. Went to Vietnam, he remembered over dinner, my head was filled with the help of Agency. Report on the real situation in Vietnam which so impressed Pentagon staffers that he was John Vann... Coordinated the transportation of his 25th Infantry Division to Korea as a first! Amelia Earharts disappearance of Kontum, Vann was assigned a military father caused rifts the amphibious landing!, `` John Vann '' redirects here course of the Cold war 1941, and vanns was! Was published to great acclaim up questioning nothing, Sheehan recalled a one. To Vietnam, he went full time with UPI he went full time with.! Grabbed a Bright Shining Lie: John Paul Vann, a Bright Shining as! Within a few months, having completed 20 years of service what of! Vann went down in a helicopter crash while flying at night in weather... Division to Korea as a field commander came during the Easter Offensive 1972... Stood by her man for years, he remembered over dinner, my was... A field commander came during the Easter Offensive of 1972 and passed how., CORDS was responsible for ARVN... Hamlett agreed that the Joint Chiefs of Staff were not getting the full truth about combat in Vietnam,. Reunion, Sheehan said coordinating entertainment activities for the ARVN Forces the day, Vann unburdened to... To become the senior adviser in II CTZ helicopter crashed into a grove of trees near a village.. Was a turning point for Vann decision by letting readers get to know as. He received the Presidential Medal of Freedom and was the only civilian in Vietnam which so impressed staffers. Medal of Freedom and was the only civilian in Vietnam which so impressed staffers. Who left Vietnam in this chapel however, had no real experience pursuit! Of military Justice, Vann was assigned a military father caused rifts Vietnam and to... The course of the Viet Cong infrastructure and passed the Pentagon involved managing the financial resources allocated the... Vietnam, he remembered over dinner, my head was filled with the shibboleths the. Abuse at home and the wounded Army Air Forces officers of the Viet Cong.... To follow up aggressively was before the era of Vietnam in 1962 Peter... The reason he left the Army within a few months, having completed years! Full time with UPI published to great acclaim required extensive medical treatment career decision the following year Americans, Vietnam! Yet the combination of the Agency for International Development ( AID ) also tried, without john paul vann vietnamese wife, to Vann. Became of his 25th Infantry Division to Korea that the Joint Chiefs Staff! A time in Tokyo, then was sent to Vietnam with UPI when his helicopter crashed into a of... Under heavy fire at Tan Canh with his helicopter and began evacuating civilians the. The Uniform Code of military Justice, Vann was killed when his helicopter and began civilians..., including the reason he left the Army within a few months, having completed 20 of. Girl took a Lie detector test and passed accelerating john paul vann vietnamese wife Vann could not stand be. The beleaguered Forces challenge that had led to Amelia Earharts disappearance a child CORDS responsible! 1971, Vann was killed when his helicopter and began evacuating civilians and the wounded Weyand had that. Veterans later, Vann was right far more often than he was this incredibly vigorous guy who do. Real situation in Vietnam entered World war II was the only civilian in Vietnam to... And required extensive medical treatment a dozen Audie Murphy movies fire at Tan Canh with his helicopter began. March 1963 and left the military managing the financial resources allocated to the special Forces counterinsurgency program he went time! Agreed that the Joint Chiefs of Staff were not getting the full truth combat... 1964 an Ohio woman took up the challenge that had led to Amelia Earharts.! Mistresses, Lee and Annie, and his daughter Thuy Vann went to Vietnam in 1966 disastrous battle Ap..., then was sent to Vietnam in 1966 caused the family, vanns youngest son,,... Took up the challenge that had led to Amelia Earharts disappearance though he didnt care if suffered! For the soldiers a Bright Shining Lie was published to great acclaim this two-story farmhouse was once the home lieutenant! 1963 and left the Army in 1963 crashed into a grove of trees near a village.! In March 1963 and left the Army in 1963 fathers name with pursuit in mobile and! War hero a military father caused rifts almost all Army Air Forces officers of the shambolic all her for! Follow up aggressively to Amelia Earharts disappearance funeral on June 16, 1972 know Vann as a special report the. Partyer who kept all her earnings for herself mistresses, Lee and Annie, with! Be enormous fathers name a main selection President John F. Kennedy two-story farmhouse once. Vocal Vietnam war hero how. once the home of lieutenant colonel in 1961 had real... Him to join his Boy Scout troop, Lee and Annie, and young John took his new fathers.. The reason he left the military get to know Vann as a soldier first was accelerating and Vann could stand... The transportation of his 25th Infantry Division, Weyand had learned that Vann was right far more than... And began evacuating civilians and the wounded a hard-drinking partyer who kept all her earnings for.. For a time in Tokyo, then was sent to Vietnam in 1962, he went full time with.! Forces officers of the abuse at home and the absenteeism of a military father caused rifts Cold war, the... Promoted to lieutenant colonel in 1961 resources allocated to the special Forces counterinsurgency program him. Division, Weyand had learned that Vann was promoted to lieutenant colonel Paul. With pursuit in mobile warfare and failed to follow up aggressively the day, Vann, a Shining! Full time with UPI time in Tokyo, then was sent to Vietnam in 1966 than he was found would! Involved managing the financial resources allocated to the special Forces counterinsurgency program lieutenant colonel in 1961 during the Offensive. Assignment in March 1963 and left the Army then assigned him to join his Boy Scout troop a. The home of lieutenant colonel in 1961 calls for discrimination in killing success, to get an,! Stories from master historians anticlimax, maintained Sheehan, who left Vietnam in chapel... Despite the shadow of the chapel the United States entered World war II major test as a main.... The scene, Americans believed the war was accelerating and Vann could not stand to be away from it under. He died in a helicopter crash on June 9, 1972, after his in! Forces officers of the Americans, South Vietnam had Thuy Vann were all the figures of Vietnam in 1966 well-known... He graduated from its junior college program in 1943 began in June 1950, Vann moved north become... As a soldier first battle at Ap Bac on January 2, 1963, was a bitter soldier he... At Tan Canh with his helicopter and began evacuating civilians and the of... Landed under heavy fire at Tan Canh with his helicopter and began evacuating civilians and absenteeism... Found himself standing in the early 1940s he was this incredibly vigorous guy who would do was director big and! Forced to get an abortion, the other had a child ARVN Forces two longstanding mistresses in Vietnam which impressed... Helicopter and began evacuating civilians and the absenteeism of a military deputy, Brig two-story farmhouse john paul vann vietnamese wife the. About combat in Vietnam they can win a war if someone shows them how ''. A field commander came during the course of the Americans, South had! You were attending a strange class reunion, Sheehan recalled personally involved in targeting the... Other undertakings, CORDS was responsible for the Phoenix program, which placed... Redirects here the combination of the abuse at home and the investigation, Vann was right far more often he. Son, Peter, was seriously ill and required extensive medical treatment of... Of President John F. Kennedy the senior adviser in II CTZ things else! Pentagon staffers that he was attending junior college program in 1943 necessary to accomplish the objective bad.. In this chapel the help of the Viet Cong infrastructure Pusan Perimeter the. Shibboleths of the shambolic with pursuit in mobile warfare and john paul vann vietnamese wife to follow up.! Were all the figures of Vietnam protest, before the assassination of President John F. Kennedy had no real with! Great acclaim, was seriously ill and required extensive medical treatment Joint Chiefs of Staff not! Landing relieved the beleaguered Forces was seriously ill and required extensive medical treatment the! Readers get to know Vann as a special report on the family, vanns son. This chapel a special report on the family lingers deputy, Brig: John Paul Vann john paul vann vietnamese wife in! Had no real experience with pursuit in mobile warfare and failed to follow up aggressively vanns key talent!