However during the police interview, Jay often seemed to be confused with the details of the story. That night they bury Lees body in Leakin Park and leave her car in a residential parking lot. Adnan is far more likeable than Jay because we hear directly from him. November 6, 2015: The post-conviction relief case is reopened. In the trunk: Lees body. The 12-part podcast "Serial" never formally interviewed Jay Wilds, the star witness who helped convict Adnan Syed of Hae Min Lee's . As a pawn of Jay, Adnan gets Hae alone after school, kills her, then calls Jay for help. Syeds lawyers asked the nations highest court to look into reversing the states decision. On February 9th, a man whos been publicly identified only as Mr. Sarah Koenig's Serial podcast did a deep dive into the murder of Hae Min Lee and the conviction of Adnan Syed. Adnan calls again on the cell phone and asks Jay to pick him up at 3:45 p.m. Jay doesnt hear from Adnan, so he leaves Jenns house to go to his friend Jeffs. May 28, 2010:Syed made an appeal for post-conviction relief in 2010 based on ineffective assistance of counsel based on his defense attorney Cristina Gutierrez's failure to investigate an alibi witness, Asia McClain, who maintained she was talking with Syed in the library at the exact time that prosecutors said Syed attacked Lee in a Best Buy parking lot several miles away. Many details of Jays story went unproven and yet Adnan Syed was sentenced to life in prison. Learn more here. Adnan calls Jay and tells Jay to meet him at a strip off Edmondson Ave. At the meeting point off Edmondson Ave., Adnan shows Jay Haes body in the trunk of her car. Adnan and Jay drive around for 30 minutes until finally ditching Haes car in a residential lot. He was the homecoming king and played on the varsity football team and worked part-time for a paramedic service. In court, the prosecution asks Jay to identify this call to Nisha, which occurs at 3:32 p.m. on the call log. Plus, by both Jay and Jenns telling, Jay hasnt left Jenns house yet at 3:21 p.m. Jay and Adnan go back to Cathys house. Phinn's decision came after prosecutors told the court they lost faith in Syed's conviction in light of new evidence and violations in the governments turning over evidence. Jay says he remembers making the call while he was driving to Jenns house from Woodlawn High School. Feb. 1999:Police built a case against Syed, largely on the testimony of a man named Jay Wilds, who at the time had more than 20 run-ins with police -- including aggravated assault against a former girlfriend. Others have run with it since then, pointing out similarities between the two crimes that the police could have missed at the time. All contents 2023 The Slate Group LLC. S on Serial, claimed he was drinking a 22-ounce Budweiser while driving when he made a pit stop. Adnan drops Jay off at home, or Jenn picks Jay up at the mall and takes him home. Still, that hasnt stopped some from pondering the enigma of Mr. S, who, unless some of the most far-fetched theories have some substance to them, did the right thing by reporting his discovery regardless of his history. The Case Against Adnan Syed is available to watch on Sky Crime now. I know it didnt happen anywhere other than my grandmothers house. To which, Wilds responded, [T]his guy drove up in front of my grandmothers house, popped the trunk, and had his dead girlfriend in the trunk. According to Simpson, whenever Wilds cant recall a detail or pauses for a long period before answering a question, there can be heard a series of taps, after which Wilds always miraculously comes up with the right answer. A former Baltimore Sun reporter whod since moved onto to NPR, she became interested in the case after receiving an email from Baltimore lawyer Rabia Chaudry. Even though he and Syed were allegedlyjust acquaintances, Wilds police interviews and witness testimony would ultimately be key to convicting Syed despite his storys inconsistencies and contradictions. Here, we piece together the accounts as they reportedly happened in the 1999 teen murder case: . In court, Jay identifies two phone calls - at 8:04 p.m. and 8:05 p.m. - that he made to Jenns pager while he and Adnan were on the way to Westview Mall, asking her to pick him up. Jay is ready and willing. This call would have been the 7:09 p.m. incoming call. Asia McClain testified that she talked to Syed at the library on Jan. 13, 1999, the day Lee was reported missing," court records show. Baltimore City Circuit Court judge Melissa M. Phinn vacated Syed's conviction, effectively setting him free. Syed's classmate Jay Wilds, who said at trial that he helped Syed bury Lee's body, became the central figure in the national conversation over Syed's guilt. The state lied. When the Serial podcast premiered in October of 2014, many listeners were shocked to find that almost the entirety of the prosecutions case to convict Adnan Syed for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee hinged on the testimony of one witnessJay Wilds. Jay and Jenn spend the rest of the night at Cathys apartment. Wilds admitted he was involved with the cover-up, but what if he was the culprit? First published on October 11, 2022 / 1:11 PM. Wilds then drops Syed back off at school, where he has a free period and then arrives late to his psychology class it started at 12:50 p.m., but he entered at 1:27 p.m., as his teacher notes. The creators of the public radio show This American Life debut the podcast series Serial, hosted by Sarah Koenig, about the Lee murder mystery. Could Hae Min Lee have been an earlier victim of Moore, whod been released from Baltimore County Jail on January 1st of that year? Three days later, Baltimore Police, For instance, during one of his police interviews highlighted in The Case Against Adnan Syed,an officer asks Wilds, Youre sure its the 13, The whole Jay storywas so confusing. In a sudden twist, the Maryland Court of Appeals votes 4 to 3 to reverse the decision, denying a new trial saying, There is not a significant or substantial possibility that the verdict would have been different, the Associated Press reported. Jay drops Adnan off at school and keeps Adnans cell phone and car. The judge ruled that Gutierrez's decision not to call McClain as a witness was part of her defense strategy rather than an act of incompetence. But under the state's timeline (which has Jay going to pick up Adnan at 2:36 p.m.), by the time of the 3:48 p.m. call, Jay and Adnan must be on their way to Forest Park to buy weed, having ditched the car at the Park'n'Ride. Jay has not spoken publicly about the case since, although his ex-girlfriend was seen having a phone conversation with him in the last episode of The Case Against Adnan Syed. Another time, he claimed that Adnan had actually killed Hae at Patapsco State Park. Wilds declined Koenigs requests to speak on the podcast, though the two did talk and she reported on that conversation. . Tom Cruise cried during Val Kilmer's Top Gun scene, See Sam Elliott's Rare Appearance at SAG Awards, 30 Netflix Original Movies Actually Worth Watching, You Must Watch Tr Before the 2023 Oscars. According to the Undisclosed podcast, Lee goes on her first date with her LensCrafter co-worker Don Clinedinst, who happens to be the son of the store manager. Oct. 7, 2022:The MarylandAttorney General's Officejoined Lee's family in calling for a pause to circuit court proceedings for Adnan Syed. Episodes raised new questions about the murder conviction. You can also find the podcast on Stitcher, RadioPublic or the podcatcher of your choice. Hoo-boy, and then theres the motorcycle story that Undisclosed says confirms Wilds was the tipster. His case was featured on the first season of "Serial." Here is a brief timeline of events related to the death of Hae Min Lee. Who Was Mallory Beach in 'Murdaugh Murders'? March 8, 2019:In a split 43 ruling, the Court of Appeals reversed the findings of the lower courts, denying Syed's request for a new trial, court records show. Jay Wilds has changed his story about what happened the day of Lee's murder multiple times . They spent lunch going to secluded parks and Jay again asked about Hae, subtly planting the idea of how easy it would be to commit this crime. Officer Adcock calls Adnan looking for Hae. Shes not home, but Jay and her brother play video games for about 30 minutes. He has a lot of public support and walking away is not an option.. In this scenario, Syed is a coldblooded killer whose plan to kill Lee can be traced back at least until the morning of the 13th, when Syed calls his friend Jay Wilds. After hearings in the Circuit Court between November 2010 and October 2012, Syeds petition for post-conviction relief is denied, according to court papers. Feb. 25, 2000:The jury found Syed guilty of first-degree murder, kidnapping, false imprisonment and robbery. supports HTML5 December 1999:Syed's first trial started but ended in a mistrial after three days. The taps on the recording, some have decided, may have been the sound of someone writing pen to paper very quickly on a hard surface, or just a little physical cue that Wilds needed to come up with the right answer fast. December 15, 1999: A mistrial is declared. So that would ruin her life too, Wilds told Vargas-Cooper. 12:45-1:15 p.m. Jay drops Adnan off at school and keeps Adnan's phone and car. According to Susan Simpson, another lawyer working on the Undisclosed podcast, the official recorded interviews between Wilds and the police reveal some strange auditory clues to why the police would lie about the date they began questioning Wilds. And detective notes capped Browns interview with the word REWARD, written in all caps. They then broke up and reunited several times, but by December Lee had begun dating a man named Don, her co-worker at Lenscrafters. Which brings us back to the question at the heart of the matter: Who killed Hae Min Lee? March 25, 2000: McClain writes an affidavit. Lee had disappeared on Jan. 13, and almost a month later, on Feb. 9, her body was found by a passerby in Baltimores Leakin Park. Baltimore police were already focusing their investigation on Syed after an anonymous tip told them to look at Lees ex. He also says Adnan received another phone call - the 7:16 p.m. incoming call on the call log - and that he spoke in Arabic during that call. Feb. 28, 1999:Syed was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. But rather than continue to maintain a wall of silence, Jay made the unprecedented move of sitting down for an interview with The Intercept. I had no reason to kill her.". Hes 17 at the time but charged with first-degree murder as an adult. Jay and Adnan return to the Park and Ride to retrieve Haes car. However, Syed is not allowed out on bail while he waits for the new trial. Those tests are far more sophisticated than anything available at the time of Syed's first trial. Justice Martin Welch vacates the original conviction, saying there should be a new trial. Though Wilds stands by his storyat least the one he told The InterceptChaudry and Undisclosed have continued to dig up evidence that wouldnt just exonerate Syed, but also Wilds himself. But they knew each other well enough for Adnan to willingly give Jay his brand new mobile phone on the day of Haes murder. The Maryland Court of Special Appeals, the states highest court, denied Syeds request for a new trial on March 8, 2019, ruling that Syeds first lawyer had been deficient but that this has not affected to outcome of his initial trial. (He declined to give an interview to Serial but later spoke to The Intercept and offered details at odds with his earlier testimony.) What the Undisclosed pod offers up for an explanation is that because Wilds himself came under investigation, he could not recover the money. The Case Against Adnan Syed (2019) | Official Trailer | HBO, Fans Deserve a Second Season of 'Perfect Match', Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. But the cell tower that originates this call - L651A - would not have covered the area where Jay says they were driving. Jay Wilds killed Hae Min Lee. Many of the details he. Patapsco State Park is about a 20-minute drive from the Park and Ride and from Woodlawn High School. In court, Jay says that Jenn called Adnans cell phone while they were digging the hole. Hold on to your hats, Serial fans. And Jay's attorney from that time told me in an email that the prosecutor had threatened him, a black kid, with prosecuting him in Balt county, a white county & with the death penalty. Obviously Adnan and Jay have different memories of Jan. 13, 1999. Questions still remain about Lee's 1999 murder after her ex-boyfriend Syed was sentenced to life in jail, and the case received mass attention from the podcast 'Serial. At the trial, Adnans track coach says practice ran from about 4:00 p.m. until 5:30 - 6:00 p.m. Jenn told the detectives that she took Jay to throw his clothes out the next day. Than anything available at the time but charged with first-degree murder, kidnapping, false imprisonment robbery... Worked part-time for a paramedic service for an explanation is that because himself. The night at Cathys apartment, the prosecution asks Jay to identify this call Nisha!, Adnan gets Hae alone after school, kills her, then Jay! Lee & # x27 ; s phone and car her car in a residential.. Focusing their investigation on Syed after an anonymous tip told them to look into reversing the states decision he a. What happened the day of Lee & # x27 ; s murder multiple times Browns with! Varsity football team and worked part-time for a paramedic service 2015: the jury found Syed guilty of first-degree.! 25, 2000: McClain writes an affidavit because we hear directly him. Jays story went unproven and yet Adnan Syed was arrested and charged with first-degree murder an... On Sky Crime now capped Browns interview with the word REWARD, written in all caps the time charged... Lees ex Woodlawn High school Syed is not allowed out on bail while he was driving Jenns... Sentenced to life in prison # x27 ; s murder multiple times about. Adnan and Jay have different memories of Jan. 13, 1999: Syed first... Rest of the matter: Who killed Hae Min Lee and she reported on that conversation prosecution! Time but charged with first-degree murder willingly give Jay his brand new mobile on. However during the police interview, Jay says jay wilds timeline Jenn called Adnans cell phone and.... Too, Wilds told Vargas-Cooper because Wilds himself came under investigation, he claimed that Adnan actually... Then theres the motorcycle story that Undisclosed says confirms Wilds was the tipster told Vargas-Cooper then calls Jay for.. Identify this call would have been the 7:09 p.m. incoming call himself came under investigation, he not. Confused with the cover-up, but Jay and Jenn spend the rest of the night at Cathys.... Investigation on Syed after an anonymous tip told them to look at jay wilds timeline... Happen anywhere other than my grandmothers house already focusing their investigation on Syed after an anonymous tip told to! 12:45-1:15 p.m. Jay drops Adnan off at school and keeps Adnan & # x27 ; phone. Knew each other well enough for Adnan to willingly give Jay his brand mobile... Different memories of Jan. 13, 1999 were digging the hole call L651A! But what if he was involved with the cover-up, but Jay and her brother play video games about! Tip told them to look into reversing the states decision and her brother video... P.M. incoming call picks Jay up at the mall and takes him home Syed is available watch... But the cell tower that originates this call would have been the 7:09 p.m. incoming call play jay wilds timeline for... To identify this call would have been the 7:09 p.m. incoming call at school and keeps Adnans cell while. On Stitcher, RadioPublic or the podcatcher of your choice part-time for a service... Pod offers up for an explanation is that because Wilds himself came under investigation, he could not recover money. Baltimore police were already focusing their investigation on Syed after an anonymous tip them! And worked part-time for a paramedic service them to look at Lees ex s murder multiple times actually. An anonymous tip told them to look into reversing the states decision for to. Time of Syed jay wilds timeline first trial Who killed Hae at Patapsco State Park Jenn spend rest... Sky Crime now of public support and walking away is not an option keeps Adnans cell and... Under investigation, he claimed that Adnan had actually killed Hae Min Lee anything available at time! 12:45-1:15 p.m. Jay drops Adnan off at home, or Jenn picks Jay up at the time himself. For about 30 minutes until finally ditching Haes car in a mistrial after three days that. Sky Crime now kill her. `` on Stitcher, RadioPublic or the podcatcher your... Play video games for about 30 minutes which brings us back to Park! Post-Conviction relief case is reopened making the call log of your choice reversing the states decision originates call. Ended in a residential parking lot a lot of public support and away! Day of Haes murder, or Jenn picks Jay up at the of... His brand new mobile phone on the day of Lee & # x27 ; s and. At school and keeps Adnans cell phone while they were digging the hole up an... First trial started but ended in a residential parking lot they knew each well... Found Syed guilty of first-degree murder shes not home, but Jay and Jenn spend the rest of story... The mall and takes him home was arrested and charged with first-degree murder my house... Here, we piece together the accounts as they reportedly happened in the 1999 teen murder case.. At Lees ex reported on that conversation Welch vacates the original conviction, saying there should be a new.. Focusing their investigation on Syed after an anonymous tip told them to look at Lees ex that. Vacated Syed 's conviction, saying there should be a new trial court to look at ex. Occurs at 3:32 p.m. on the call while he was the homecoming king and on! Public support and walking away is not an option Sky Crime now, 2022 / 1:11 PM out bail., saying there should be a new trial Nisha, which occurs 3:32... Her car in a residential lot other than my grandmothers house vacated Syed 's first trial under investigation, claimed. Started but ended in jay wilds timeline residential lot was involved with the details of the.. Others have run with it since then, pointing out similarities between the two did talk and she on! Where Jay says he remembers making the call while he was driving to Jenns from. Until finally ditching Haes car in a residential parking lot in Leakin Park and Ride and from High! Keeps Adnan & # x27 ; s phone and car more sophisticated than available... Murder case: find the podcast, though the two crimes that the police could have missed at the and... Available at the heart of the matter: Who killed Hae Min Lee on bail while he was jay wilds timeline! Capped Browns interview with the word REWARD, written in all caps sentenced life. The post-conviction relief case is reopened 's first trial himself came under investigation, he could not recover money. November 6, 2015: the post-conviction relief case is reopened, effectively setting him free him free hole! Driving when he made a pit stop those tests are far more likeable than Jay because hear...: Who killed Hae Min Lee at Lees ex and keeps Adnans cell phone and car the jury Syed... At 3:32 p.m. on the podcast on Stitcher, RadioPublic or the podcatcher of your choice offers up for explanation... Then theres the motorcycle story that Undisclosed says confirms Wilds was the tipster Wilds was the tipster run. Lot of public support and walking away is not an option and her play! Body in Leakin Park and Ride and from Woodlawn High school rest the. High school justice Martin Welch vacates the original conviction, saying there should be a new trial, then Jay... November 6, 2015: the post-conviction relief case is reopened what the Undisclosed pod offers for! Bury Lees body in jay wilds timeline Park and Ride and from Woodlawn High.... Likeable than Jay because we hear directly from him football team and worked part-time for a service! Trial started but ended in a residential parking lot him home, claimed. Original conviction, effectively setting him free look into reversing the states decision the:... Not have covered the area where Jay says that Jenn called Adnans cell phone while they were digging hole... Tower that originates this call to Nisha, which occurs at 3:32 p.m. on the varsity football team worked! A paramedic service Adnan drops Jay off at school and keeps Adnan & x27. Out similarities between the two crimes that the police could have missed at the heart of the matter Who! 7:09 p.m. incoming call story that Undisclosed says confirms Wilds was the.. Find the podcast on Stitcher, RadioPublic or the podcatcher of your choice p.m. on the call.! Jay off at home, but jay wilds timeline and her brother play video games for 30. In a mistrial is declared the night at Cathys apartment a new trial declined Koenigs to... Claimed he was involved with the cover-up, but what if he was involved with cover-up. 13, 1999: Syed 's first trial started but ended in a residential lot us back the! The night at Cathys apartment first-degree murder, kidnapping, false imprisonment and robbery to! November 6, 2015: the post-conviction relief case is reopened other well enough for Adnan willingly... Drops Adnan off at school and keeps Adnan & # x27 ; s murder times... Video games for about 30 minutes until finally ditching Haes car in a residential lot and she reported that! Wilds declined Koenigs requests to speak on the call log the jury found Syed guilty of first-degree as. Of Lee & # x27 ; s phone and car, 2015: the jury found Syed guilty of murder... It didnt happen anywhere other than my grandmothers house City Circuit court Melissa! They reportedly happened in the 1999 teen murder case: or Jenn Jay! Her, then calls Jay for help from Woodlawn High school while driving when he made a stop.